Opened 12 months ago

Last modified 12 months ago

#8490 open defect

AES HLS stream downloading don't work

Reported by: mark99i Owned by:
Priority: important Component: avformat
Version: git-master Keywords: hls regression
Cc: mark.smirnow87@gmail.com Blocked By:
Blocking: Reproduced by developer: yes
Analyzed by developer: no

Description

Summary of the bug:
How to reproduce:

ffmpeg -report -user_agent "VKAndroidApp/5.52-4532 (Android 9.0; SDK 28; arm64-v8a; Xiaomi MI 6; ru; 1920x1080)" -i "https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg" -loglevel debug -c copy output6.mp3
ffmpeg version 4.1.4-1build2 Copyright (c) 2000-2019 the FFmpeg developers
built with gcc 9 (Ubuntu 9.2.1-4ubuntu1)

when you try to download an hls stream encrypted with aes, an warnings
[mpegts @ 0x55e00b00e140] Continuity check failed for pid 5907 expected 8 got 2
[mpegts @ 0x55e00b00e140] Packet had TEI flag set; marking as corrupt
and the result is a file half the size and with audio freezes

I found a working example of how hls is successfully decrypted if you pre-download all chunks, it works fine on latest release.

Also i find old ffmpeg version N-59742-gd9481dc built on Jan 9 2014 22:01:53 with gcc 4.8.2 (GCC), where works great -i $link -c copy out.mp3, which doesn't work on new versions

Attachments (3)

ffmpeg-20200120-031856.log (213.7 KB) - added by mark99i 12 months ago.
index_hls_aes_example.m3u8 (18.7 KB) - added by mark99i 12 months ago.
if the link is not available
hls_aes_with_chunks_example.zip (1.8 MB) - added by mark99i 12 months ago.

Change History (9)

Changed 12 months ago by mark99i

Changed 12 months ago by mark99i

if the link is not available

comment:1 Changed 12 months ago by cehoyos

  • Component changed from ffmpeg to undetermined
  • Keywords hls aes removed
  • Resolution set to duplicate
  • Status changed from new to closed
  • Version changed from 4.1.4 to unspecified

Looks like #3493.

Changed 12 months ago by mark99i

comment:2 follow-up: Changed 12 months ago by mark99i

  • Cc mark.smirnow87@gmail.com added
  • Component changed from undetermined to avformat
  • Resolution duplicate deleted
  • Status changed from closed to reopened
  • Version changed from unspecified to 4.1.4

dear cehoyos,
why did you close the ticket if there is another error?
bug #3493 was fixed around 2016, as the 2016 version works. And this ticket is a new bug.

comment:3 in reply to: ↑ 2 ; follow-up: Changed 12 months ago by cehoyos

  • Component changed from avformat to undetermined
  • Resolution set to invalid
  • Status changed from reopened to closed
  • Version changed from 4.1.4 to unspecified

Replying to mark99i:

bug #3493 was fixed around 2016

Why do you think so?

For future tickets, please understand that there is no release support on this bug tracker.

Your url works fine here:

$ ffmpeg -user_agent "VKAndroidApp/5.52-4532 (Android 9.0; SDK 28; arm64-v8a; Xiaomi MI 6; ru; 1920x1080)" -i "https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg" out.aac
ffmpeg version N-96438-gb5dba152ef Copyright (c) 2000-2020 the FFmpeg developers
  built with gcc 9 (SUSE Linux)
  configuration: --enable-gpl --enable-gnutls --enable-libx264 --enable-libx265 --enable-libaom
  libavutil      56. 38.100 / 56. 38.100
  libavcodec     58. 66.100 / 58. 66.100
  libavformat    58. 35.104 / 58. 35.104
  libavdevice    58.  9.103 / 58.  9.103
  libavfilter     7. 71.100 /  7. 71.100
  libswscale      5.  6.100 /  5.  6.100
  libswresample   3.  6.100 /  3.  6.100
  libpostproc    55.  6.100 / 55.  6.100
[hls] Skip ('#EXT-X-ALLOW-CACHE:YES')
[hls] Skip ('#EXT-X-VERSION:3')
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/key.pub?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/c3Z2xocHp-dSt4YWMpPShgNA.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/95e2NmIDcgazQ.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/bbcmFrJj0jaDU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
Input #0, hls, from 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg':
  Duration: 00:03:06.88, start: 0.127122, bitrate: N/A
  Program 0 
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
    Stream #0:0: Audio: mp3 ([3][0][0][0] / 0x0003), 44100 Hz, stereo, fltp, 320 kb/s
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
    Stream #0:1: Data: timed_id3 (ID3  / 0x20334449)
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
Stream mapping:
  Stream #0:0 -> #0:0 (mp3 (mp3float) -> aac (native))
Press [q] to stop, [?] for help
Output #0, adts, to 'out.aac':
  Metadata:
    encoder         : Lavf58.35.104
    Stream #0:0: Audio: aac (LC), 44100 Hz, stereo, fltp, 128 kb/s
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
      encoder         : Lavc58.66.100 aac
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/bfa2dudnt8dSp6aWssPy5rOg.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/dacmZnKzovZDM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/81em1tJzUlaj0.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -3 -3
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -2 -2
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f4Ymxuf3F8eil6YGguMSthNQ.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/27eGRqLTwvbDE.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/5bc2htITcnZjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/93ZmhtfHl6fSZ2aW8oMDkhazU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/eed29oKDM9L2Y5.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/d2fGlkIjQ1KWs4.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -5 -5
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/7eYGhseHR5fCF-Y2MjPTosaTY.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/04cmJqKzo3IWI_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/e7e2BoKTswI2U0.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -7 -7
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/78aGZicHF5cS9zYGwgNTAtYjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/b6dmlpITo7L2gz.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/c5f2RsLDI8LW08.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/abY2xtdXl-cCp0Z2snOzknZjc.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f5dWBpKjUxImQ7.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f7cmdoJTMzLWk-.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -3 -3
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/beam1gfXZ0dC11YGsiOjYjZjs.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/02f2FhIjM1LmIy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/2fe2NvKTs3Imsy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9db21ic3R8cS99aWQiMDIobjU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/6dcmhmJDU2I2o9.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/59f2RvLTc1KWMy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9eZ2tpdnd1dyJ6ZWcqPj8paDk.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/05fGBpID0_LGI_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/02f2FhIjI2LmIy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/42aWNidXR2eCtybmwkMDoqbjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/65cmdjKDIxIWU_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/67f2NkIzkyLmEz.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -7 enddists: -2 -2
[mp3float] overread, skip -8 enddists: -6 -6
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f0ampuf3h_fiNya20uOj8hbjY.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9ecWBtKT0wLmw4.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/85cGdnKjU3J20_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -8 -8
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/d9YGhieXR_fyh8YWYmMjIgbDg.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/2cfGtlKDY7LWM1.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/22fWhkIjs9JG8_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -2 -2
size=    1146kB time=00:01:45.00 bitrate=  89.4kbits/s speed=11.5x    
video:0kB audio:1125kB subtitle:0kB other streams:0kB global headers:0kB muxing overhead: 1.884918%
[aac] Qavg: 566.994

Please only reopen this ticket if you can reproduce the issue with current FFmpeg git head.

comment:4 in reply to: ↑ 3 Changed 12 months ago by mark99i

  • Component changed from undetermined to avformat
  • Keywords aes hls added
  • Resolution invalid deleted
  • Status changed from closed to reopened
  • Version changed from unspecified to git-master

Replying to cehoyos:

Replying to mark99i:

bug #3493 was fixed around 2016

Why do you think so?

For future tickets, please understand that there is no release support on this bug tracker.

Your url works fine here:

$ ffmpeg -user_agent "VKAndroidApp/5.52-4532 (Android 9.0; SDK 28; arm64-v8a; Xiaomi MI 6; ru; 1920x1080)" -i "https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg" out.aac
ffmpeg version N-96438-gb5dba152ef Copyright (c) 2000-2020 the FFmpeg developers
  built with gcc 9 (SUSE Linux)
  configuration: --enable-gpl --enable-gnutls --enable-libx264 --enable-libx265 --enable-libaom
  libavutil      56. 38.100 / 56. 38.100
  libavcodec     58. 66.100 / 58. 66.100
  libavformat    58. 35.104 / 58. 35.104
  libavdevice    58.  9.103 / 58.  9.103
  libavfilter     7. 71.100 /  7. 71.100
  libswscale      5.  6.100 /  5.  6.100
  libswresample   3.  6.100 /  3.  6.100
  libpostproc    55.  6.100 / 55.  6.100
[hls] Skip ('#EXT-X-ALLOW-CACHE:YES')
[hls] Skip ('#EXT-X-VERSION:3')
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/key.pub?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/c3Z2xocHp-dSt4YWMpPShgNA.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/95e2NmIDcgazQ.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/bbcmFrJj0jaDU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
Input #0, hls, from 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg':
  Duration: 00:03:06.88, start: 0.127122, bitrate: N/A
  Program 0 
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
    Stream #0:0: Audio: mp3 ([3][0][0][0] / 0x0003), 44100 Hz, stereo, fltp, 320 kb/s
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
    Stream #0:1: Data: timed_id3 (ID3  / 0x20334449)
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
Stream mapping:
  Stream #0:0 -> #0:0 (mp3 (mp3float) -> aac (native))
Press [q] to stop, [?] for help
Output #0, adts, to 'out.aac':
  Metadata:
    encoder         : Lavf58.35.104
    Stream #0:0: Audio: aac (LC), 44100 Hz, stereo, fltp, 128 kb/s
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
      encoder         : Lavc58.66.100 aac
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/bfa2dudnt8dSp6aWssPy5rOg.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/dacmZnKzovZDM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/81em1tJzUlaj0.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -3 -3
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -2 -2
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f4Ymxuf3F8eil6YGguMSthNQ.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/27eGRqLTwvbDE.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/5bc2htITcnZjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/93ZmhtfHl6fSZ2aW8oMDkhazU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/eed29oKDM9L2Y5.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/d2fGlkIjQ1KWs4.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -5 -5
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/7eYGhseHR5fCF-Y2MjPTosaTY.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/04cmJqKzo3IWI_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/e7e2BoKTswI2U0.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -7 -7
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/78aGZicHF5cS9zYGwgNTAtYjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/b6dmlpITo7L2gz.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/c5f2RsLDI8LW08.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/abY2xtdXl-cCp0Z2snOzknZjc.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f5dWBpKjUxImQ7.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f7cmdoJTMzLWk-.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -3 -3
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/beam1gfXZ0dC11YGsiOjYjZjs.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/02f2FhIjM1LmIy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/2fe2NvKTs3Imsy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9db21ic3R8cS99aWQiMDIobjU.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/6dcmhmJDU2I2o9.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/59f2RvLTc1KWMy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9eZ2tpdnd1dyJ6ZWcqPj8paDk.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/05fGBpID0_LGI_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/02f2FhIjI2LmIy.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/42aWNidXR2eCtybmwkMDoqbjM.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/65cmdjKDIxIWU_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/67f2NkIzkyLmEz.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -7 enddists: -2 -2
[mp3float] overread, skip -8 enddists: -6 -6
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/f0ampuf3h_fiNya20uOj8hbjY.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/9ecWBtKT0wLmw4.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/85cGdnKjU3J20_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -9 enddists: -8 -8
[https] Opening 'crypto+https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/d9YGhieXR_fyh8YWYmMjIgbDg.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[https] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/2cfGtlKDY7LWM1.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[hls] Opening 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/705edff09e4fb2/22fWhkIjs9JG8_.ts?extra=0gZkt5A98nmk7mpQMZEgDr46nY3YEf-5jANqVH2lhiW41L9c79MYai4EKLXs8mszTfxBFjK-IgUKI885pLorWCwcqB7r3tZdC8m9NkMrJdhmEgB2fAR42QRYX1BaSBM2WjQl97dBzWY-QE_eZkQcEKEmOu8' for reading
[mp3float] overread, skip -5 enddists: -2 -2
size=    1146kB time=00:01:45.00 bitrate=  89.4kbits/s speed=11.5x    
video:0kB audio:1125kB subtitle:0kB other streams:0kB global headers:0kB muxing overhead: 1.884918%
[aac] Qavg: 566.994

Please only reopen this ticket if you can reproduce the issue with current FFmpeg git head.

this link downloads the file without errors, but as a result, the out.aac file is broken.
the file contains lags, jumps and time lasts almost 2 times less than the original.
the errors that I specified in the first post can be seen by adding -loglevel debug
I checked on the ffmpeg version-20200115-0dc0837-win64-static and this bug is reproduced

for comparison, you can find the old version, and there the download works correctly, and the file size is 3 MB at this link, but not 1-2

ffmpeg -user-agent "VKAndroidApp/5.52-4532 (Android 9.0; SDK 28; arm64-v8a; Xiaomi MI 6; ru; 1920x1080)" -i "https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg" out.aac
ffmpeg version N-59742-gd9481dc Copyright (c) 2000-2014 the FFmpeg developers
  built on Jan  9 2014 22:01:53 with gcc 4.8.2 (GCC)
  configuration: --enable-gpl --enable-version3 --disable-w32threads --enable-avisynth --enable-bzlib --enable-fontconfig --enable-frei0r --enable-gnutls --enable-iconv --enable-libass --enable-libbluray --enable-libcaca --enable-libfreetype --enable-libgsm --enable-libilbc --enable-libmodplug --enable-libmp3lame --enable-libopencore-amrnb --enable-libopencore-amrwb --enable-libopenjpeg --enable-libopus --enable-librtmp --enable-libschroedinger --enable-libsoxr --enable-libspeex --enable-libtheora --enable-libtwolame --enable-libvidstab --enable-libvo-aacenc --enable-libvo-amrwbenc --enable-libvorbis --enable-libvpx --enable-libwavpack --enable-libx264 --enable-libxavs --enable-libxvid --enable-zlib
  libavutil      52. 62.100 / 52. 62.100
  libavcodec     55. 47.101 / 55. 47.101
  libavformat    55. 22.103 / 55. 22.103
  libavdevice    55.  5.102 / 55.  5.102
  libavfilter     4.  1.100 /  4.  1.100
  libswscale      2.  5.101 /  2.  5.101
  libswresample   0. 17.104 /  0. 17.104
  libpostproc    52.  3.100 / 52.  3.100
Input #0, hls,applehttp, from 'https://cs9-21v4.vkuseraudio.net/p18/4b5e6e00549/5f33cfb56a4dd7/index.m3u8?extra=wa1yB-mCLiOotud3kyD6dEB0hqvTzDgYeVvdrfcLLAykSjHBEJRi1g9enf-c73wZ768tbfBUV-LI04Qze6z73kUzlKlt2tDa6yoBsm6gQWq6JATaQ-GgWIHu7DqT4uyYDSv7rDnsDucP1zh7xxgOENJ7Yg':
  Duration: 00:03:06.88, start: 0.127122, bitrate: N/A
  Program 0
    Metadata:
      variant_bitrate : 0
    Stream #0:0: Audio: mp3 ([3][0][0][0] / 0x0003), 44100 Hz, stereo, s16p, 320 kb/s
    Stream #0:1: Data: timed_id3 (ID3  / 0x20334449)
Output #0, adts, to 'out.aac':
  Metadata:
    encoder         : Lavf55.22.103
    Stream #0:0: Audio: aac (libvo_aacenc), 44100 Hz, stereo, s16, 128 kb/s
Stream mapping:
  Stream #0:0 -> #0:0 (mp3 -> libvo_aacenc)
Press [q] to stop, [?] for help
size=    2920kB time=00:03:06.86 bitrate= 128.0kbits/s
video:0kB audio:2920kB subtitle:0 global headers:0kB muxing overhead 0.000000%

comment:5 Changed 12 months ago by cehoyos

  • Keywords regression added; aes removed
  • Reproduced by developer set
  • Status changed from reopened to open

Needs -http_persistent false

comment:6 Changed 12 months ago by cehoyos

  • Priority changed from normal to important
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.