Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #2099, comment 50


Ignore:
Timestamp:
Feb 12, 2013, 5:18:34 PM (3 years ago)
Author:
cehoyos
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #2099, comment 50

    initial v1  
    33 
    44I understand that, please read the following: 
    5 I originally asked for "proof" that it makes sense to allow muxing TrueHD mov/isom. (I expected that this is would not be possible but otoh I couldn't know if you have access to Dolby reference software - that quite certainly allows to test and verify - or not.) You did not present any such hint that it makes sense if FFmpeg allows muxing TrueHD into mov (on the contrary imo). But please read on because from your point of you, this does not matter! 
     5I originally asked for "proof" that it makes sense to allow muxing TrueHD mov/isom. (I expected that this would not be possible but otoh I couldn't know if you have access to Dolby reference software - that quite certainly allows to test and verify - or not.) You did not present any such hint that it makes sense if FFmpeg allows muxing TrueHD into mov (on the contrary imo). But please read on because from your point of you, this does not matter! 
    66 
    77The mov/isom muxer/demuxer is written in a way that makes sure that every format that can be read automatically can also be written (in a possibly wrong way but still).